Tufty

Row counter app vs clicker: which one keeps count better?

A clicker costs little, needs no screen and never asks for an update. An app can hold more than one number and undo a slip. Which is better depends on what you’re counting.

Updated November 16, 2026 · 6 min read

Every counting method does the same job: remember a number while your hands are busy. The difference is in what happens when things go wrong. You press twice, the counter gets knocked in your bag, or the pattern asks you to track rows, stitches and repeats at the same time. This guide compares the physical counters crafters actually use with counter apps, and shows when each one is the better choice.

The quick answer

  • A clicker or barrel counter is best for simple projects with one number to track: a scarf, a blanket in one stitch, plain socks. It’s cheap, quick and needs no phone.
  • An app is best when you need more than one number (rows, stitches in a long row, which repeat you’re in), when you want undo, or when you keep several projects going at once.
  • Both works well too: a clicker for rows at the sofa, and an app or the pattern margin for the bigger picture.

The physical counters

Barrel counters

A small cylinder with number wheels that slides onto a straight knitting needle. You turn the dial by hand at the end of each row. They’re very cheap, light and silent, and because they sit on the needle they travel with the work. The catch: they only fit straight needles of certain sizes, you have to remember to turn them, and they don’t work for crochet unless you hang one on a stitch marker.

Press clickers

A push-button counter: press once and the number goes up by one. Clover’s Kacha-Kacha is the best-known one among knitters and crocheters, and many come on a cord you can wear around your neck. Press clickers are fast and you can use them without looking, but a press in your bag counts too, and most models can’t go back one without starting from zero. Some have a lock to stop accidental presses.

Finger and ring counters

A small digital counter on a ring or a strap that you press with your thumb. Your hand never leaves the yarn, which crocheters especially like. Most have a reset button and some have a minus button. They run on a small battery and the buttons are tiny.

Pencil and paper

Not a gadget, but still one of the most reliable methods: tick each row on a printed pattern or a sticky note. You can see a whole repeat at a glance, and there’s nothing to break. The pencil has to be where you are, and long projects make messy pages.

What a clicker does well

  • No screen. No notifications, no phone battery to worry about, nothing to unlock.
  • Speed. You can press a clicker without looking or putting the hook down.
  • Cost. Usually a few dollars, less than many balls of yarn.
  • One project, one counter. Leave the clicker in the project bag and the count stays with the work.

Where a clicker loses count

  • One number only. A pattern line like “Rnd 7: (sc 5, inc) x6 (42)” needs the round number and your place in the round. A single counter can track one of them.
  • No undo. Press twice by mistake and most clickers can’t go back one. You have to recount the fabric or remember to subtract.
  • Bag bumps. A clicker without a lock can change in a project bag, and you won’t know by how much.
  • No history. It can’t tell you when you last counted or which repeat you’re in.

What a row counter app adds

  • Several counts at once: rows, a stitch count that starts again every row, and a repeat count (“repeat 3 of 6”).
  • Undo for the tap you didn’t mean, and a minus button.
  • A lock so taps in your bag or on the sofa cushion don’t count.
  • Reminders on a row: “decrease on rows 6, 12, 18”, “insert safety eyes after round 10”.
  • Several projects, each remembering its own place.
  • Counting without opening the app. Some apps put the counter on the Lock Screen or a widget, or let you count by voice or a hardware button.

The costs are real too: your phone has to be near the work, its battery matters, and a free app may come with ads or limits. Our honest comparison of row counter apps covers what each costs and where it falls short.

Side by side

Clicker or barrel counterRow counter app
Numbers it keepsOneRows, stitches, repeats
Undo a mistakeRarelyYes
Accidental countsIn the bag, unless it locksPrevented by a lock mode
Use without lookingYesYes, if the button is big or on the Lock Screen
Needs a phoneNoYes
Several projectsOne clicker eachYes
CostA few dollarsFree versions exist; paid plans vary

When to use which

Pick a clicker when…

  • The project is one long count: a garter scarf, a blanket worked in rows of the same stitch.
  • You want your phone out of reach while you craft.
  • You knit with straight needles and like a barrel counter that travels with the work.

Pick an app when…

  • The pattern repeats: “rows 1–4, eight times” is two numbers.
  • You’re making amigurumi, where you need the round and your place in it. See how to count rounds in amigurumi.
  • You have shaping on certain rows and want a reminder.
  • You often press twice and need undo.

Use both when…

You like the feel of a clicker for rows, but need to track repeats or several pieces. Count rows on the clicker and update the app (or the pattern margin) at the end of each repeat. Many crafters also keep a marker in every 10th row as a backup whatever they count with; see how to count rows in crochet for that habit.

Try a counter in your browser first

If you’re not sure an app is for you, try the idea first with our free online row counter. It runs in the browser with a row count, a stitch count and undo, and nothing to install. If you like counting on a screen, an app adds what a browser can’t: the Lock Screen, widgets and several saved projects.

Where Tufty fits

Tufty is our row and stitch counter for crochet and knitting. We built it to feel as quick as a clicker: the whole card is the button, so you can tap it without looking, and a lock mode ignores bag bumps. Then it does what a clicker can’t: the stitch count resets every row, a repeat counter shows “repeat 3 of 6”, undo is always on screen, and on iPhone you can count from the Lock Screen, a widget, Siri or the Action Button. Counting is free with no ads; Tufty Pro adds unlimited projects and counting by voice. It doesn’t have an Apple Watch app. If counting on your wrist matters most, some other counter apps do.

Common questions

What is a kacha-kacha counter?

Kacha-Kacha is Clover’s push-button row counter, named after the sound it makes. Many crafters use the name for any press clicker.

Is a digital row counter better than a mechanical one?

Not by itself. A digital ring counter is still one number. What changes things is whether it can hold several counts, undo, and lock. That’s where apps differ from both.

Can I use a clicker for crochet?

Yes. A press clicker on a cord or a ring counter works well for crochet. Barrel counters are made for straight knitting needles, so they’re less handy for crochet.

Do I need a counter at all?

For short or simple pieces, no: count the fabric or tick the pattern. Counters earn their place on long or repeating patterns, and on anything with matching pieces such as sleeves or socks.